I recently came across another duo of lookalike covers: Jumping in Sunset by Dawn Ringling (published in 2003 by Multnomah Books) and Under the Mercy Trees by Heather Newton (published in 2011 by Harper Paperbacks).
Weirdly enough, while I was looking up publishing info for these two books on Amazon, I came across five (!) other familiar covers...
The first was My Soul to Keep by Melanie Wells, which actually has at least five other copycat covers:
T’es pas ma mère (which literally means You’re Not My Mother) by Prune Berge is one of them. Hop over to this “similar covers” post to see the other four.
Next, I came across Straight Up by Lisa Samson, which has two lookalike covers:
Imagined London: A Tour of the World’s Greatest Fictional City by Anna Quindlen is the book that immediately popped into my head when I saw the cover for Straight Up, but a TinEye search revealed another lookalike: Astonishing Splashes of Colour by Clare Morrall.
Finally, another one of Lisa Samson’s novels has a lookalike cover: Songbird looks suspiciously like The Winter Sea by Susanna Kearsley (though TinEye doesn’t recognize them as being the same).
Come back next week for the other two (which are both part of a large set of copycat covers)!